{ "id": 421593, "title": "That's Genious: Even the coolest Kaggler shall make reviews (Kaggle AI Report 2023)", "url": "/competitions/2023-kaggle-ai-report/discussion/421593", "author_name": "", "post_date": "2023-07-06T00:39:51.199648100Z", "votes": 19, "comment_count": 7, "views": 0, "content": "

You shall Not pass without making a Peer-Feedback

\n

That below is Tolkien's trilogy part I. Don't mistake it with a shameful voting ring.
\n\"\"https://www.prairiegrownreviews.com/you-shall-not-pass-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-review/

\n

PEER-FEEDBACK INSTRUCTIONS:

\n

\"Peer-feedback must take the form of a public comment on the bottom of a Kaggle Notebook that is attached to the AI Report Competition. Your feedback should provide constructive criticism to the original author and qualitatively assess how well they met the essay grading rubric expectations.\"

\n

\"Requirement: Provide comments with peer-feedback for a total of 3 different essays.
\nPrioritize peer-feedback for notebooks on the same topic you wrote about.\"

\n

\"Try to not provide feedback on notebooks that already have three constructive comments. If every notebook on your topic already has 3 or more comments providing peer-feedback, you can instead provide peer-feedback on a notebook from a different topic that does not yet have 3 comments on it.\"

\n

https://www.kaggle.com/competitions/2023-kaggle-ai-report/overview/peer-feedback-instructions

\n

Therefore, if you're low-profile, shy or cool. Don't forget to make your reviews. At least, three.

", "messages": [ { "id": "2332077", "postDate": "07/06/2023 00:39:51", "content": "

You shall Not pass without making a Peer-Feedback

\n

That below is Tolkien's trilogy part I. Don't mistake it with a shameful voting ring.
\n\"\"https://www.prairiegrownreviews.com/you-shall-not-pass-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-review/

\n

PEER-FEEDBACK INSTRUCTIONS:

\n

\"Peer-feedback must take the form of a public comment on the bottom of a Kaggle Notebook that is attached to the AI Report Competition. Your feedback should provide constructive criticism to the original author and qualitatively assess how well they met the essay grading rubric expectations.\"

\n

\"Requirement: Provide comments with peer-feedback for a total of 3 different essays.
\nPrioritize peer-feedback for notebooks on the same topic you wrote about.\"

\n

\"Try to not provide feedback on notebooks that already have three constructive comments. If every notebook on your topic already has 3 or more comments providing peer-feedback, you can instead provide peer-feedback on a notebook from a different topic that does not yet have 3 comments on it.\"

\n

https://www.kaggle.com/competitions/2023-kaggle-ai-report/overview/peer-feedback-instructions

\n

Therefore, if you're low-profile, shy or cool. Don't forget to make your reviews. At least, three.

", "rawMarkdown": "#You shall Not pass without making a Peer-Feedback\n\nThat below is Tolkien's trilogy part I. Don't mistake it with a shameful voting ring.\n![](https://www.googleapis.com/download/storage/v1/b/kaggle-forum-message-attachments/o/inbox%2F3012786%2F6f85a2ce4d1fe84fff6614c2541695a3%2Fimages.jpg?generation=1688602440751043&alt=media)https://www.prairiegrownreviews.com/you-shall-not-pass-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-review/\n\nPEER-FEEDBACK INSTRUCTIONS:\n\n\"Peer-feedback must take the form of a public comment on the bottom of a Kaggle Notebook that is attached to the AI Report Competition. Your feedback should provide constructive criticism to the original author and qualitatively assess how well they met the essay grading rubric expectations.\"\n\n\"Requirement: Provide comments with peer-feedback for a total of 3 different essays.\nPrioritize peer-feedback for notebooks on the same topic you wrote about.\"\n\n\"Try to not provide feedback on notebooks that already have three constructive comments. If every notebook on your topic already has 3 or more comments providing peer-feedback, you can instead provide peer-feedback on a notebook from a different topic that does not yet have 3 comments on it.\"\n\nhttps://www.kaggle.com/competitions/2023-kaggle-ai-report/overview/peer-feedback-instructions\n\n#Therefore, if you're low-profile, shy or cool. Don't forget to make your reviews. At least, three.", "votes": null }, { "id": "2332474", "postDate": "07/06/2023 08:09:43", "content": "

@mpwolke : thanks a lot for your prompt and encouragement!

\n

Btw, which of your public notebooks have you decided to make the official submission to the contest?

", "rawMarkdown": "mpwolke : thanks a lot for your prompt and encouragement!\n\nBtw, which of your public notebooks have you decided to make the official submission to the contest?", "votes": null }, { "id": "2332786", "postDate": "07/06/2023 12:39:06", "content": "

Hi Georgii,
\nin general, I don't read all the competitions rules. Only after I made a couple of Notebooks I realized that it wasn't necessary to work with any code. 😁

\n

I submitted: \"The Mediocre Man Teaming Up ChatGPT\"

\n

Cause it was an opportunity to check José Inginieros ideas and his work from 1913 and compare to The (talk of the year 2023) ChatGPT. A match with more than 100 hundred years difference.

\n

It's about The Aurea Mediocritas (ethics, virtue and honesty).

\n

And, a little funny thing about rankings at the end. Which is my peculiar aesthetic essence.

", "rawMarkdown": "Hi Georgii,\nin general, I don't read all the competitions rules. Only after I made a couple of Notebooks I realized that it wasn't necessary to work with any code. 😁\n\nI submitted: \"The Mediocre Man Teaming Up ChatGPT\" \n\nCause it was an opportunity to check José Inginieros ideas and his work from 1913 and compare to The (talk of the year 2023) ChatGPT. A match with more than 100 hundred years difference.\n\nIt's about The Aurea Mediocritas (ethics, virtue and honesty).\n\nAnd, a little funny thing about rankings at the end. Which is my peculiar aesthetic essence.", "votes": null }, { "id": "2332798", "postDate": "07/06/2023 12:42:17", "content": "

@mpwolke : thanks, very nice! I will check it out to leave the feedback within the constructive-feedback framework established by this contest.

\n

Thank you once again for inspiring topics, both in your discussions and the research avenues you selected for your contest contribution.

\n

Good luck!

", "rawMarkdown": "mpwolke : thanks, very nice! I will check it out to leave the feedback within the constructive-feedback framework established by this contest.\n\nThank you once again for inspiring topics, both in your discussions and the research avenues you selected for your contest contribution.\n\nGood luck!", "votes": null }, { "id": "2333123", "postDate": "07/06/2023 17:08:27", "content": "

Hi, I am new to this competition. I have a question about peer reviews. So basically, I need to comment and review on 3papers, but where is the comment section of each paper or notebook?

", "rawMarkdown": "Hi, I am new to this competition. I have a question about peer reviews. So basically, I need to comment and review on 3papers, but where is the comment section of each paper or notebook?", "votes": null }, { "id": "2333155", "postDate": "07/06/2023 17:24:13", "content": "

@fatemehfazlali : Hi Fatemeh,

\n

It is not a rocket science - you will be able to get around it quickly. Let's review it by example, using Marilia's submission notebook

\n\n

Good luck!

", "rawMarkdown": "fatemehfazlali : Hi Fatemeh,\n\nIt is not a rocket science - you will be able to get around it quickly. Let's review it by example, using Marilia's submission notebook\n\n- go to the notebook you would like to leave a comment for (https://www.kaggle.com/code/mpwolke/the-mediocre-man-teaming-up-chatgpt/ , in our case)\n- click on Comments tab at the top of the notebook view - you will be navigated to the area of the comments to the notebook\n- once you are in the comments area, you can publish the text of your comment, similar to what you do when you publish a comment to a discussion topic\n\nGood luck!", "votes": null }, { "id": "2333368", "postDate": "07/06/2023 22:52:22", "content": "

Hi Fatemeh Fazlali,

\n

Once you have already submitted very likely you have seen on the top of you Notebook (or any other Notebook) the comments on top.

\n

We have on top (Notebook, Input, Output, Logs and Comments). Click on Comments to leave your peer feedback on 3 Notebooks. Write your review on that markdown cell/comment field.

\n

By the way, all of us are learning on this new kind of competition.

\n

Additionally, I left a comment on your Notebook that still have No title.

", "rawMarkdown": "Hi Fatemeh Fazlali,\n\nOnce you have already submitted very likely you have seen on the top of you Notebook (or any other Notebook) the comments on top. \n\nWe have on top (Notebook, Input, Output, Logs and Comments). Click on Comments to leave your peer feedback on 3 Notebooks. Write your review on that markdown cell/comment field.\n\nBy the way, all of us are learning on this new kind of competition.\n\nAdditionally, I left a comment on your Notebook that still have No title.", "votes": null }, { "id": "2333394", "postDate": "07/06/2023 23:29:01", "content": "

Thanks. I should have paid more attention, but this was my first notebook on Kaggle.😅

", "rawMarkdown": "Thanks. I should have paid more attention, but this was my first notebook on Kaggle.😅", "votes": null } ], "comments": [ { "id": 2332474, "author_name": "gvyshnya", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 08:09:43", "content": "

@mpwolke : thanks a lot for your prompt and encouragement!

\n

Btw, which of your public notebooks have you decided to make the official submission to the contest?

", "votes": null, "replies": [ { "id": 2332786, "author_name": "mpwolke", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 12:39:06", "content": "

Hi Georgii,
\nin general, I don't read all the competitions rules. Only after I made a couple of Notebooks I realized that it wasn't necessary to work with any code. 😁

\n

I submitted: \"The Mediocre Man Teaming Up ChatGPT\"

\n

Cause it was an opportunity to check José Inginieros ideas and his work from 1913 and compare to The (talk of the year 2023) ChatGPT. A match with more than 100 hundred years difference.

\n

It's about The Aurea Mediocritas (ethics, virtue and honesty).

\n

And, a little funny thing about rankings at the end. Which is my peculiar aesthetic essence.

", "votes": null, "replies": [ { "id": 2332798, "author_name": "gvyshnya", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 12:42:17", "content": "

@mpwolke : thanks, very nice! I will check it out to leave the feedback within the constructive-feedback framework established by this contest.

\n

Thank you once again for inspiring topics, both in your discussions and the research avenues you selected for your contest contribution.

\n

Good luck!

", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ] } ] }, { "id": 2333123, "author_name": "fatemehfazlali", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 17:08:27", "content": "

Hi, I am new to this competition. I have a question about peer reviews. So basically, I need to comment and review on 3papers, but where is the comment section of each paper or notebook?

", "votes": null, "replies": [ { "id": 2333155, "author_name": "gvyshnya", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 17:24:13", "content": "

@fatemehfazlali : Hi Fatemeh,

\n

It is not a rocket science - you will be able to get around it quickly. Let's review it by example, using Marilia's submission notebook

\n\n

Good luck!

", "votes": null, "replies": [] }, { "id": 2333368, "author_name": "mpwolke", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 22:52:22", "content": "

Hi Fatemeh Fazlali,

\n

Once you have already submitted very likely you have seen on the top of you Notebook (or any other Notebook) the comments on top.

\n

We have on top (Notebook, Input, Output, Logs and Comments). Click on Comments to leave your peer feedback on 3 Notebooks. Write your review on that markdown cell/comment field.

\n

By the way, all of us are learning on this new kind of competition.

\n

Additionally, I left a comment on your Notebook that still have No title.

", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ] }, { "id": 2333394, "author_name": "fatemehfazlali", "author_url": "", "post_date": "07/06/2023 23:29:01", "content": "

Thanks. I should have paid more attention, but this was my first notebook on Kaggle.😅

", "votes": null, "replies": [] } ], "raw_markdown_by_id": { "2332077": "#You shall Not pass without making a Peer-Feedback\n\nThat below is Tolkien's trilogy part I. Don't mistake it with a shameful voting ring.\n![](https://www.googleapis.com/download/storage/v1/b/kaggle-forum-message-attachments/o/inbox%2F3012786%2F6f85a2ce4d1fe84fff6614c2541695a3%2Fimages.jpg?generation=1688602440751043&alt=media)https://www.prairiegrownreviews.com/you-shall-not-pass-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-review/\n\nPEER-FEEDBACK INSTRUCTIONS:\n\n\"Peer-feedback must take the form of a public comment on the bottom of a Kaggle Notebook that is attached to the AI Report Competition. Your feedback should provide constructive criticism to the original author and qualitatively assess how well they met the essay grading rubric expectations.\"\n\n\"Requirement: Provide comments with peer-feedback for a total of 3 different essays.\nPrioritize peer-feedback for notebooks on the same topic you wrote about.\"\n\n\"Try to not provide feedback on notebooks that already have three constructive comments. If every notebook on your topic already has 3 or more comments providing peer-feedback, you can instead provide peer-feedback on a notebook from a different topic that does not yet have 3 comments on it.\"\n\nhttps://www.kaggle.com/competitions/2023-kaggle-ai-report/overview/peer-feedback-instructions\n\n#Therefore, if you're low-profile, shy or cool. Don't forget to make your reviews. At least, three.", "2332474": "mpwolke : thanks a lot for your prompt and encouragement!\n\nBtw, which of your public notebooks have you decided to make the official submission to the contest?", "2332786": "Hi Georgii,\nin general, I don't read all the competitions rules. Only after I made a couple of Notebooks I realized that it wasn't necessary to work with any code. 😁\n\nI submitted: \"The Mediocre Man Teaming Up ChatGPT\" \n\nCause it was an opportunity to check José Inginieros ideas and his work from 1913 and compare to The (talk of the year 2023) ChatGPT. A match with more than 100 hundred years difference.\n\nIt's about The Aurea Mediocritas (ethics, virtue and honesty).\n\nAnd, a little funny thing about rankings at the end. Which is my peculiar aesthetic essence.", "2332798": "mpwolke : thanks, very nice! I will check it out to leave the feedback within the constructive-feedback framework established by this contest.\n\nThank you once again for inspiring topics, both in your discussions and the research avenues you selected for your contest contribution.\n\nGood luck!", "2333123": "Hi, I am new to this competition. I have a question about peer reviews. So basically, I need to comment and review on 3papers, but where is the comment section of each paper or notebook?", "2333155": "fatemehfazlali : Hi Fatemeh,\n\nIt is not a rocket science - you will be able to get around it quickly. Let's review it by example, using Marilia's submission notebook\n\n- go to the notebook you would like to leave a comment for (https://www.kaggle.com/code/mpwolke/the-mediocre-man-teaming-up-chatgpt/ , in our case)\n- click on Comments tab at the top of the notebook view - you will be navigated to the area of the comments to the notebook\n- once you are in the comments area, you can publish the text of your comment, similar to what you do when you publish a comment to a discussion topic\n\nGood luck!", "2333368": "Hi Fatemeh Fazlali,\n\nOnce you have already submitted very likely you have seen on the top of you Notebook (or any other Notebook) the comments on top. \n\nWe have on top (Notebook, Input, Output, Logs and Comments). Click on Comments to leave your peer feedback on 3 Notebooks. Write your review on that markdown cell/comment field.\n\nBy the way, all of us are learning on this new kind of competition.\n\nAdditionally, I left a comment on your Notebook that still have No title.", "2333394": "Thanks. I should have paid more attention, but this was my first notebook on Kaggle.😅" }, "source": "meta" }