{
  "id": 413576,
  "title": "Wrong annotations for y-ticks and y data-series in extracted data",
  "url": "/competitions/benetech-making-graphs-accessible/discussion/413576",
  "author_name": "Sohyun Sim",
  "post_date": "2023-05-29T10:18:57.813000",
  "votes": 3,
  "comment_count": 0,
  "views": 0,
  "content": "<p>There are some data with a wrong annotation among extracted data. For example, the y-ticks of the chart are from 20 to -25, but they are all annotated as positive values. The data series are shown the same way so that they indicate wrong values.</p>\n<pre><code>Filename:  cc68f19b708c\n\nx_ticks:  ['10%', '20%', '30%', '40%', '50%', '60%', '70%', '80%']\ny_ticks:  ['20', '15', '10', '5', '0', '5', '10', '15', '20', '25']\nsource:  extracted\nchart-type:  line\n</code></pre>\n<p><img src=\"https://www.kaggleusercontent.com/kf/131430328/eyJhbGciOiJkaXIiLCJlbmMiOiJBMTI4Q0JDLUhTMjU2In0..A8-jPWxUNcmTyabNSbr-OQ.ezFfhUHyKqWH_YWSuAjrgS0twtD1z-iyZqLSPd79qw-mVwN2ku9cVDCBiqkHvWkYTJMQOPOj-XD6qQexLecmolzUCE99YFE7OjTVIegLPISVdqtLM2XNYCvFlO3pvi5Fz_ibddbMWXBBtA88pRpvJdBtztA2eTUyd21djXvb6ib7QR2PaS80XDhhBzsmE1NmfGiYc3nr1TZOly6AJWEvXuMJ44E6CSSuRr2-dEqtbyfY34Tev62WdFthkFQazgcyCAVAvF6KLN-N1FrYYeujiMruG_HMRZrD5mBoI_lkjs_69exZmIaE6MtRg_HnSezavFNna6GSk8xhgkws-S7j3YExmrCbyuR2RPWh4XHu9uPZIqdslDbm2YYyBL4TYOO80HTU0E_yhXNeazPadpTaYwhAPgYaGjpFFoQEcXYQVoW69WdswYgFG7FqBIIqYrv9kf3vyShMzVKCAsrkR50kRkUo-5VUIlmjmoGohZ_DgyVEZ8VWST42A1QbRtaFeAX8AOYS7_Vhx3q1wQRNSsVs_7OVvD_LbdtMsiknCWv9nMBGCccgEqC8NX4NaEv6E0Je4Sd8udHHX30sUu7w_ymQqIe4RWVId6ltbbsYBSjJMh6uV58BIGvJFnYW6SICP7mNGlK_QjrFRL3ZhDw9fQBRpbvcL1XZYoO-I2-MgQ_Lolk.SG1JA0SzNnx8H0gcthCctg/__results___files/__results___5_1.png\" alt=\"cc68f19b708c\"></p>\n<p>Besides negative values, you can find more examples of other cases in <a href=\"https://www.kaggle.com/code/sohyunsim/benetech-data-validation/notebook\" target=\"_blank\">my notebook</a>.<br>\nGenerated data could have the same issue, of course, but I focused on extracted data because the test data are extracted entirely.</p>\n<p>I want to know:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>if any data annotated improperly is in the test set,</li>\n<li>and, in this case, how the data will be evaluated.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Just a few days left, but I look forward to your response!</p>\n<p>(* Please note that it is a different question from <a href=\"https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/alejopaullier/benetech-wrong-annotations\" target=\"_blank\">this discussion</a>, which pointed out the bounding box issue.)</p>",
  "messages": [
    {
      "id": 2279379,
      "postDate": "2023-05-29T10:18:57.813Z",
      "content": "<p>There are some data with a wrong annotation among extracted data. For example, the y-ticks of the chart are from 20 to -25, but they are all annotated as positive values. The data series are shown the same way so that they indicate wrong values.</p>\n<pre><code>Filename:  cc68f19b708c\n\nx_ticks:  ['10%', '20%', '30%', '40%', '50%', '60%', '70%', '80%']\ny_ticks:  ['20', '15', '10', '5', '0', '5', '10', '15', '20', '25']\nsource:  extracted\nchart-type:  line\n</code></pre>\n<p><img src=\"https://www.kaggleusercontent.com/kf/131430328/eyJhbGciOiJkaXIiLCJlbmMiOiJBMTI4Q0JDLUhTMjU2In0..A8-jPWxUNcmTyabNSbr-OQ.ezFfhUHyKqWH_YWSuAjrgS0twtD1z-iyZqLSPd79qw-mVwN2ku9cVDCBiqkHvWkYTJMQOPOj-XD6qQexLecmolzUCE99YFE7OjTVIegLPISVdqtLM2XNYCvFlO3pvi5Fz_ibddbMWXBBtA88pRpvJdBtztA2eTUyd21djXvb6ib7QR2PaS80XDhhBzsmE1NmfGiYc3nr1TZOly6AJWEvXuMJ44E6CSSuRr2-dEqtbyfY34Tev62WdFthkFQazgcyCAVAvF6KLN-N1FrYYeujiMruG_HMRZrD5mBoI_lkjs_69exZmIaE6MtRg_HnSezavFNna6GSk8xhgkws-S7j3YExmrCbyuR2RPWh4XHu9uPZIqdslDbm2YYyBL4TYOO80HTU0E_yhXNeazPadpTaYwhAPgYaGjpFFoQEcXYQVoW69WdswYgFG7FqBIIqYrv9kf3vyShMzVKCAsrkR50kRkUo-5VUIlmjmoGohZ_DgyVEZ8VWST42A1QbRtaFeAX8AOYS7_Vhx3q1wQRNSsVs_7OVvD_LbdtMsiknCWv9nMBGCccgEqC8NX4NaEv6E0Je4Sd8udHHX30sUu7w_ymQqIe4RWVId6ltbbsYBSjJMh6uV58BIGvJFnYW6SICP7mNGlK_QjrFRL3ZhDw9fQBRpbvcL1XZYoO-I2-MgQ_Lolk.SG1JA0SzNnx8H0gcthCctg/__results___files/__results___5_1.png\" alt=\"cc68f19b708c\"></p>\n<p>Besides negative values, you can find more examples of other cases in <a href=\"https://www.kaggle.com/code/sohyunsim/benetech-data-validation/notebook\" target=\"_blank\">my notebook</a>.<br>\nGenerated data could have the same issue, of course, but I focused on extracted data because the test data are extracted entirely.</p>\n<p>I want to know:</p>\n<ul>\n<li>if any data annotated improperly is in the test set,</li>\n<li>and, in this case, how the data will be evaluated.</li>\n</ul>\n<p>Just a few days left, but I look forward to your response!</p>\n<p>(* Please note that it is a different question from <a href=\"https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/alejopaullier/benetech-wrong-annotations\" target=\"_blank\">this discussion</a>, which pointed out the bounding box issue.)</p>",
      "rawMarkdown": "There are some data with a wrong annotation among extracted data. For example, the y-ticks of the chart are from 20 to -25, but they are all annotated as positive values. The data series are shown the same way so that they indicate wrong values.\n\n```\nFilename:  cc68f19b708c\n\nx_ticks:  ['10%', '20%', '30%', '40%', '50%', '60%', '70%', '80%']\ny_ticks:  ['20', '15', '10', '5', '0', '5', '10', '15', '20', '25']\nsource:  extracted\nchart-type:  line\n```\n\n![cc68f19b708c](https://www.kaggleusercontent.com/kf/131430328/eyJhbGciOiJkaXIiLCJlbmMiOiJBMTI4Q0JDLUhTMjU2In0..A8-jPWxUNcmTyabNSbr-OQ.ezFfhUHyKqWH_YWSuAjrgS0twtD1z-iyZqLSPd79qw-mVwN2ku9cVDCBiqkHvWkYTJMQOPOj-XD6qQexLecmolzUCE99YFE7OjTVIegLPISVdqtLM2XNYCvFlO3pvi5Fz_ibddbMWXBBtA88pRpvJdBtztA2eTUyd21djXvb6ib7QR2PaS80XDhhBzsmE1NmfGiYc3nr1TZOly6AJWEvXuMJ44E6CSSuRr2-dEqtbyfY34Tev62WdFthkFQazgcyCAVAvF6KLN-N1FrYYeujiMruG_HMRZrD5mBoI_lkjs_69exZmIaE6MtRg_HnSezavFNna6GSk8xhgkws-S7j3YExmrCbyuR2RPWh4XHu9uPZIqdslDbm2YYyBL4TYOO80HTU0E_yhXNeazPadpTaYwhAPgYaGjpFFoQEcXYQVoW69WdswYgFG7FqBIIqYrv9kf3vyShMzVKCAsrkR50kRkUo-5VUIlmjmoGohZ_DgyVEZ8VWST42A1QbRtaFeAX8AOYS7_Vhx3q1wQRNSsVs_7OVvD_LbdtMsiknCWv9nMBGCccgEqC8NX4NaEv6E0Je4Sd8udHHX30sUu7w_ymQqIe4RWVId6ltbbsYBSjJMh6uV58BIGvJFnYW6SICP7mNGlK_QjrFRL3ZhDw9fQBRpbvcL1XZYoO-I2-MgQ_Lolk.SG1JA0SzNnx8H0gcthCctg/__results___files/__results___5_1.png)\n\nBesides negative values, you can find more examples of other cases in [my notebook](https://www.kaggle.com/code/sohyunsim/benetech-data-validation/notebook).\nGenerated data could have the same issue, of course, but I focused on extracted data because the test data are extracted entirely.\n\n\nI want to know:\n- if any data annotated improperly is in the test set,\n- and, in this case, how the data will be evaluated.\n\nJust a few days left, but I look forward to your response!\n\n(* Please note that it is a different question from [this discussion](https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/alejopaullier/benetech-wrong-annotations), which pointed out the bounding box issue.)",
      "votes": 3
    }
  ],
  "comments": [],
  "raw_markdown_by_id": {
    "2279379": "There are some data with a wrong annotation among extracted data. For example, the y-ticks of the chart are from 20 to -25, but they are all annotated as positive values. The data series are shown the same way so that they indicate wrong values.\n\n```\nFilename:  cc68f19b708c\n\nx_ticks:  ['10%', '20%', '30%', '40%', '50%', '60%', '70%', '80%']\ny_ticks:  ['20', '15', '10', '5', '0', '5', '10', '15', '20', '25']\nsource:  extracted\nchart-type:  line\n```\n\n![cc68f19b708c](https://www.kaggleusercontent.com/kf/131430328/eyJhbGciOiJkaXIiLCJlbmMiOiJBMTI4Q0JDLUhTMjU2In0..A8-jPWxUNcmTyabNSbr-OQ.ezFfhUHyKqWH_YWSuAjrgS0twtD1z-iyZqLSPd79qw-mVwN2ku9cVDCBiqkHvWkYTJMQOPOj-XD6qQexLecmolzUCE99YFE7OjTVIegLPISVdqtLM2XNYCvFlO3pvi5Fz_ibddbMWXBBtA88pRpvJdBtztA2eTUyd21djXvb6ib7QR2PaS80XDhhBzsmE1NmfGiYc3nr1TZOly6AJWEvXuMJ44E6CSSuRr2-dEqtbyfY34Tev62WdFthkFQazgcyCAVAvF6KLN-N1FrYYeujiMruG_HMRZrD5mBoI_lkjs_69exZmIaE6MtRg_HnSezavFNna6GSk8xhgkws-S7j3YExmrCbyuR2RPWh4XHu9uPZIqdslDbm2YYyBL4TYOO80HTU0E_yhXNeazPadpTaYwhAPgYaGjpFFoQEcXYQVoW69WdswYgFG7FqBIIqYrv9kf3vyShMzVKCAsrkR50kRkUo-5VUIlmjmoGohZ_DgyVEZ8VWST42A1QbRtaFeAX8AOYS7_Vhx3q1wQRNSsVs_7OVvD_LbdtMsiknCWv9nMBGCccgEqC8NX4NaEv6E0Je4Sd8udHHX30sUu7w_ymQqIe4RWVId6ltbbsYBSjJMh6uV58BIGvJFnYW6SICP7mNGlK_QjrFRL3ZhDw9fQBRpbvcL1XZYoO-I2-MgQ_Lolk.SG1JA0SzNnx8H0gcthCctg/__results___files/__results___5_1.png)\n\nBesides negative values, you can find more examples of other cases in [my notebook](https://www.kaggle.com/code/sohyunsim/benetech-data-validation/notebook).\nGenerated data could have the same issue, of course, but I focused on extracted data because the test data are extracted entirely.\n\n\nI want to know:\n- if any data annotated improperly is in the test set,\n- and, in this case, how the data will be evaluated.\n\nJust a few days left, but I look forward to your response!\n\n(* Please note that it is a different question from [this discussion](https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/alejopaullier/benetech-wrong-annotations), which pointed out the bounding box issue.)"
  }
}